Buttercream icing

Many people have asked me for my buttercream icing recipe and I am really happy to share it today :)

This recipe makes the SOFTEST and FLUFFIEST frosting ever! 

best buttercream icing ever 1

You can use it to frost your cakes and cupcakes or even make icing decorations like flowers. 

This recipe is modified from an AWESOME flour frosting my Mom makes AND Wilton’s buttercream icing.

best buttercream icing ever 2

The addition of FLOUR is the key to the VELVETTY texture of my buttercream!

People worry that they would taste the flour but NOPE… You won’t taste it at all! ;)

best buttercream icing ever 3

Unlike typical buttercream icings, my recipe takes a bit more time to prepare and there are a few more steps.

But trust me…this frosting is WORTH the extra effort :)

best buttercream icing ever 4

To make this frosting, you will need the following ingredients: 
2 cups shortening (I like to use 1 cup shortening and 1 cup butter) 
4 – 6 cups powdered sugar (based on your taste preference) 
1/4 cup all purpose flour 
1 cup milk (I use vanilla flavored almond milk…you can use whatever milk you like) 
1 tbsp vanilla extract (If you want pure white icing, use the clear vanila extract and not the brown one. I usually buy mine from Michaels or Hobby Lobby)
1 tsp almond extract
1 tbsp meringue powder (optional…I feel that this helps in stabilizing my icing) 

VARIATIONS:
- To make peppermint icing, omit other other extracts and add 1 tbsp peppermint extract or more if you want it very minty. 
- To make rose icing, omit all other extracts and add 1 tbsp rose water or even more if you want a very strong flavor and fragrance.
You can also make rose icing by using 3-4 tablespoons of a rose syrup called “Rooh Afza.” It’s a sweet syrup which is sold at Indian grocery stores. However, due to its pink color, your icing will become slightly pinkish. 
- To make coconut icing, you can use coconut milk instead of other types of milks and add 1 tbsp of coconut extract instead of other extracts. If you like a slightly chunky coconut forsting, add 1 cup of finely shredded coconut after Step 7. You will need to add a about 1/3 cup more milk to smooth out your frosting. 

Here are the steps for my basic buttercream icing:

Step 1: 
In a non-stick saucepan, add flour, milk and 1 cup of powdered sugar. The mixture will be lumpy.
best buttercream icing ever 5
Step 2:
Heat this mixture at medium to low heat. You will need to constantly keep mixing with a whisk or a wooden spoon until everything dissolves and there are no lumps.
best buttercream icing ever 6
Step 3:
When the mixture gets thick and starts sticking to your spoon, remove this saucepan from the heat and allow it to cool and come down to room temperature.
best buttercream icing ever 7
Step 4: 
Now… in a deep bowl, add shortening and butter (if you are using it) as well as meringue powder and vanilla extract.
Mix until it starts to get a little fluffy.
best buttercream icing ever 8Step 5: 
Now, add sugar a little at a time and keep mixing (I add 1/2 cup at a time).
best buttercream icing ever 9Step 6: 
After you have added about 3 cups of powdered sugar…add the flour mixture into this bowl. 
PLEASE make sure your flour mixture is at room temperature.
If it’s hot, your butter and shortening will start to melt and it will be a disaster.
best buttercream icing ever 10Step 7: 
Mix everything properly again. 
At this point, taste your frosting to see if you are satisfied with the sweetness. If not, you can add more powdered sugar. 
And you are done!
best buttercream icing ever 11
NOTES:
- Normally, I don’t have to add additional milk or water to smooth out my frosting but if the weather in your area or the temperature in your house is being temperamental, you may need to add a couple of tablespoons of water to mix your frosting properly. 
- This frosting is NOT white. It’s kinda “off-white.” I have not figured out any way to make it pure white but I don’t really care coz I tend to color my frostings…hehe.

- Before filling a piping bag and icing your cake, let this frosting sit in the refrigerator for 30- 45 minutes. It’s easier to pipe this way.

- Use gel colors to tint your icing. If you want your icing to be red, I have noticed Americolor’s red gel color works best. It seems to have a deeper shade of red than compared to Wilton’s red gel color. 

I REALLY hope you guys try out this frosting coz I honestly think it tastes a gazillion times better than typical buttercream icings!

And if you liked this frosting, you may like some of these other frosting/icing recipes:

Strawberry frosting (No seeds!)

strawberry frosting

Chocolate buttercream icing

chocolate buttercream icing

Glace icing

glace icing

Until next time, tata my lovelies :)

12 thoughts on “Buttercream icing

  1. cakewhiz

    @Nafisa… Flavor wise, using only vegetable shortening or even using only 2 cups of butter is fine. There might be a minor difference since butter adds a nice subtle flavor. But, using all butter will not be suitable for areas with high temperatures and humid climate. Shortening adds stability to a frosting and without that, your frosting will be very soft and melt very easily. Hope this helps :)

    Reply
  2. Sadie

    Just made this frosting with my Son to fill cookies for school it turned out amazing we added peppermint oil and made sandwich cookies. This was easy and I will be making this my go to frosting. Thanks for the pictures and recipe.

    Reply
    1. Abeer Rizvi Post author

      I have never tried anything aside from meringue powder. So, I am not sure what else you can use. You can omit it completely, if you like. The icing may not be very stable though, especially in heat…

      Reply
  3. dona

    have you tried cornstarch instead of flour? We us a variation of this in my area as the frosting for Red Velvet Cakes. Cornstarch leaves frosting a whiter shade

    Reply
    1. Abeer Rizvi Post author

      Hey Dona,
      I haven’t tried this frosting with cornstarch but that’s a great suggestion. I will give it a shot soon coz I am personally not too fond of the off-white color and white frosting would just be awesome! I will be sure to update the post when I try that modification :)

      Reply
    1. Abeer Rizvi Post author

      Actually, this frosting will never be truly white because of the use of flour. It’s always going to be slightly off-white color but that’s fine with me coz I usually color my icing anyways. Someone mentioned in the comments above you that using cornflour instead of all purpose flour can retain the white color. I have to try that out though…

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>